Phish.net: a Project of the Mockingbird Foundation


Mystery Jam Monday Part 127

Posted 2 years ago by lumpblockclod - 32 comments Link: http://phi.sh/b/50ea4924, posted in the Audio category (1137 listens)

Happy New Year from Mystery Jam HQ here at Phish.net. For the 127th installment of the MJ, we've selected a jam that will delight and confound... or just be solved by 12:45. It really could go either way. As usual we will be playing for an MP3 download, courtesy of our friends at LivePhish.com / Nugs.Net. The rules haven't changed: you need to correctly identify the song and the date to win. Post your guess in the comments. One guess per person per day (with the second “day” starting after I post the hint). A hint will be posted on Tuesday (if necessary) and the answer will be posted on Wednesday. Good luck...

Wednesday Answer: Congrats to conradjohansen for being the first to identify the 12/28/03 "Frankie Says." The Blog will return on Monday with MJMCXXVIII.

LivePhish.com

Comments

ShowOfMYFE Reply
Down With Disease 12/30/12
Score: 0
ShowOfMYFE Reply
Rock, Paper, Scissors?
Score: 0
Phart_Door Reply
Phart_Door Nah, that's 2.0 for sure. I'll go with the Suzy Greenberg from 12/28/03.
Score: 0
dyn0mite Reply
dyn0mite @Phart_Door said:
Nah, that's 2.0 for sure. I'll go with the Suzy Greenberg from 12/28/03.
could definitely be from that miami run...does sound very 2.0ish
Score: 0
DanceTheJig728 Reply
DanceTheJig728 Shot in the dark

12/02/03 Rock and Roll
Score: 0
officercookies Reply
officercookies 11/23 1997 gin,

literally no idea though, been bouncing from 3.0, to 2.0 from dwd to maze to piper to C+P
Score: 0
ucpete Reply
ucpete First thought was 2.0 as well. In fact, I'm pretty sure I've heard this before FWIW though that doesn't narrow it down (I've listened to every 2.0 and 3.0 show!).
Score: 0
ucpete Reply
ucpete (That is the *exact* same tone in the Miami Suzy)
Score: 0
TwiceBitten Reply
TwiceBitten Walls of the Cave 12/31/02
Score: 0
bl002e Phish.net Staff Reply
bl002e Think I have it. Should be a pretty narrow search window...
Score: 0
bl002e Phish.net Staff Reply
bl002e Confirmed!
Score: 0
MiguelSanchez Reply
MiguelSanchez i'm stuck on this one. it's definitely 2.0, and it's definitely not the 12/30/12 dwd.
Score: 0
ucpete Reply
ucpete @conradjohansen said:
12/28/03 Frankie Says
God dammit I'm an idiot. I should have realized. I blasted through all the jammy songs from Miami '03, even thinking "that Frankie looks a little long..." but got distracted with some Vegas '04. Nice one.
Score: 1
ucpete Reply
ucpete And to make it even more frustrating, I recognized that as being the same tone as the Suzy... from the same night! Because his pedals WERE on the exact same setting a few songs later.
Score: 1
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose That Miami run was sloppy at times but definitely not short on jams, risks and fun. Oddly enough, for New Year's runs post 1.0, I'd rank the two Miami ones above all the MSGs, with 09 and 03 neck and neck for the top spot. If Summer 03 was Trey's "sober tour," did things fall apart for him in December 03?
Score: 0
officercookies Reply
officercookies Anyone got good quality dl for 03 Miami run?
Score: 0
bl002e Phish.net Staff Reply
bl002e @ucpete said:
@conradjohansen said:
12/28/03 Frankie Says
God dammit I'm an idiot. I should have realized. I blasted through all the jammy songs from Miami '03, even thinking "that Frankie looks a little long..." but got distracted with some Vegas '04. Nice one.

I had to sit on my hands to not type how close you were, but I didn't want to influence the game. I can't remember which past MJM it was, but I'm almost positive a very similar thing happened to me once. Half-satisfying knowing how close you were, but half-torturous as well.

@andrewrose said:
That Miami run was sloppy at times but definitely not short on jams, risks and fun. Oddly enough, for New Year's runs post 1.0, I'd rank the two Miami ones above all the MSGs, with 09 and 03 neck and neck for the top spot. If Summer 03 was Trey's "sober tour," did things fall apart for him in December 03?
If I was a betting man, just from the tapes, I'd put Trey's 2003 off-the-wagon moment at around the break between the second and third sets on the second day of It. The 46 Days is easily the least focused of the super-extended summer 2003 jams, and the raspiness and randomness of Trey's mid-Antelope banter approach Bonnaroo '02/Vegas '04 levels.

IMO.
Score: 3
bl002e Phish.net Staff Reply
bl002e And as far as ranking the post-1.0 NYE runs, the two Miami runs are certainly at least near the top. The 2010 and 2012 runs are absolute contenders as well. The 12/31/10 Ghost, 1/1/11 set II, 12/28/12 set II, and 12/30/12 set II all push those two runs at the top, as well. I'm guessing no one's really arguing that the 2002 and 2011 runs belong above the other four anyway, though.

When comparing and rating shows, if anything I tend to overcompensate against any possible bias I'd naturally have from being at a given show. That said, I'm not sure this past 2012 run gets beat by any of the other five, despite 12/29/12 being a (relative) clunker. 2003 is probably its only rival in my mind.
Score: 1
Hose_jam Reply
Hose_jam If you didn't realize this was a 03/04 from Trey's tone...well, you are still a noob :-)
Score: 3
MiguelSanchez Reply
MiguelSanchez Damn, that's Frankie says?!

I need to brush up on Miami '03. I don't think I've listened to it since, well, early '04...
Score: 0
ucpete Reply
ucpete @MiguelSanchez said:
Damn, that's Frankie says?!

I need to brush up on Miami '03. I don't think I've listened to it since, well, early '04...
Yeah it's a weird one. In some sense, it's Frankie Says > Crazy Dark Jam, as there aren't many remnants of Frankie in the ensuing jam that ultimately lands on Llama. Miami '03 is worth checking out again if it's really been that long. The PFunk stuff I can live without, but overall it's a solid run as @andrewrose and @bl002e point out.
Score: 0
sumacdrive22 Reply
sumacdrive22 12/28/03 Frankie Says
Score: -1
FACTSAREUSELESS Reply
My first thought was summer '03, so I started checking.....someone posted 12/2/03, but I knew that wasn't it, I know that show like the back of my hand....

Never would've guessed Frankie Says...
Score: 0
MiguelSanchez Reply
MiguelSanchez @ucpete said:
@MiguelSanchez said:
Damn, that's Frankie says?! I need to brush up on Miami '03. I don't think I've listened to it since, well, early '04...
Yeah it's a weird one. In some sense, it's Frankie Says > Crazy Dark Jam, as there aren't many remnants of Frankie in the ensuing jam that ultimately lands on Llama. Miami '03 is worth checking out again if it's really been that long. The PFunk stuff I can live without, but overall it's a solid run as @andrewrose and @bl002e point out.
yeah, as much as i like p funk, that section does little to nothing for me. as for the rest of the run, i remember enjoying some of the jams, but i remember it being a little "choppy," for lack of a better term. i'll have to pull it down this week and give it a spin.
Score: 0
bl002e Phish.net Staff Reply
bl002e My appreciation for Miami 2003 is certainly in spite of the P-Funk medley. I fucking love Parliament/Funkadelic/George Clinton, and I'm sure live at the show, that whole segment was an absolute blast, but it's an auto-skip when listening to it.
Score: 0
jmira002 Reply
Destiny Unbound....i'm still fuzzy from New Years Run...brain farting...
Score: 0
metawhy Reply
metawhy The 12/29/03 show from Miami is a doozy, especially set II.
Score: 0
Poizon45 Reply
Poizon45 Happy New Years Phishermen! Can't wait to hear the shows get announced this year!
Score: 0
ucpete Reply
ucpete @sumacdrive22 said:
12/28/03 Frankie Says
Why do you guess the correct answer after the fact almost every week?
Score: 3

You must be logged in to leave a comment!

Username

Password




Register | Forgot Password

Login Register