It looks like there's a Phish show in progress! You can discuss it here x

Phish.net: a Project of the Mockingbird Foundation


Mystery Jam Monday Part 126

Posted 2 years ago by lumpblockclod - 61 comments Link: http://phi.sh/b/50ce9049, posted in the Audio category (1085 listens)

Welcome to Mystery Jam Monday Part 126 here at Phish.net. This jam was hand picked by @bl002e, the third professor to receive tenure here at Mystery Jam University. As usual we will be playing for an MP3 download, courtesy of our friends at LivePhish.com / Nugs.Net. The rules haven't changed: you need to correctly identify the song and the date to win. Post your guess in the comments. One guess per person per day (with the second “day” starting after I post the hint). A hint will be posted on Tuesday (if necessary) and the answer will be posted on Wednesday. Good luck...

Wednesday Answer: Congrats to MomaDan for correctly ID'ing the 7/20/99 "Misty Mountain Hop," and kudos to bl002e for a nice MJ selection. That said, it just goes to show how hard it is to stump the users. And with that, the Blog is going to call it a year. Mystery Jam Mondays will return in 2013...

LivePhish.com

Comments

mattsox94 Reply
mattsox94 It's either a Waves or DWD...

Waves 2/24/03
Score: 0
mcgrupp81 Reply
Let's try 7/17/99 DWD.
Score: 0
WayIFeel Reply
WayIFeel 9.22.99 Ghost
Score: 0
phil97 Reply
phil97 12/4/99 dwd
Score: 0
davarama Reply
Piper 12/17/99
Score: 0
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose 4/17/04 Pebbles and Marbles
Score: 0
jragz44 Reply
Ghost 7/23/99
Score: 0
pflaumja Reply
pflaumja DWD 11-17-97
Score: 0
bl002e Phish.net Staff Reply
bl002e I think I have it figured out. Doesn't it sound like that jam they did in that song they played on that tour that year, or am I crazy?
Score: 0
jragz44 Reply
Does sound like a pebble now.
Score: 0
Choda Reply
Choda 12/31/99 Down with Disease
Score: 0
ucpete Reply
ucpete First thought was 2.0. Agreed with @andrewrose that it's a P&M. It's in the right key for it... didn't pick up on it in 4/17/04. I'm going to go with:

Pebbles and Marbles 2/20/03
Score: 0
DWD585 Reply
Must be DWD. 7/22/97 I'll say
Score: 0
dyn0mite Reply
dyn0mite immediately thought it was 2/22/2003 Gin....but nope....back to the drawing board.
Score: 0
unogreen4 Reply
Coventry DWD
Score: 0
DanceTheJig728 Reply
DanceTheJig728 First thought was definitely a Ghost but it surely sounds more like a P&M
Score: 0
mikh2wg Reply
mikh2wg 7/9/99 Weekapaug Groove
Score: 0
Satansdogs23 Reply
7/17/03 Pebbles and Marbles
Score: 0
phellow Reply
7-08-2000 Piper
Score: 0
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose Well it sounded like a Down with Disease to me, so much so that I figured it was a red herring. Also sounded 2.0 so I figured P&M. Only thing is I couldn't detect it in any version that I had which is all of 2003. 4/17/04 was a blind guess.. Have never heard it but remember reading it was a scorcher. Don't hear it in any other 03 ones though. Maybe it is a Disease...
Score: 0
jmponder Reply
jmponder I really don't think it's from 2.0. Trey's tone just isn't indicative of that era, to me it sounds like '99 or '00
Score: 0
ProfessorDude Reply
I also hear 2.0. It has that characteristically "muddy" sound, combined with the heavy use of whammy pedal (and the flubs). But I was hearing a Rock n Roll type vamp underneath.
Score: 0
herbpowell Reply
herbpowell Light 5.31.09
Score: 0
ucpete Reply
ucpete This sounds *so* similar to the Pebbles and Marbles jams of 2.0 but I haven't been able to pin it down, and I have every 2.0 show... hmmm... maybe it's a double reverse red herring? And I didn't realize that the jam for DWD is in the same key as P&M. Someone will figure this out, but I'm still guessing 2.0...
Score: 0
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose It could be 99 or 2000..
Score: 0
napoleon Reply
First tube 7/3/11
Score: 1
TheDeputy Reply
TheDeputy I don't know, but it's fun to think about. I feel like this should be a known jam. Like, if somebody had this tape and listened to it with any regularity they will know this jam immediately. Anyway, I'd rule out 2.0, Trey's tone is not gritty enough.
I'd say it's something summer 99. For example, everybody loves Camden 99, especially the whammy part nearer to the end. Anyway, I feel that the whammy bending use came to be summer 99. And in this clip, Trey is learning about it, playing with it, getting his kicks with his 'new' toy. Also, to support 99, at about 41 seconds Trey hit's/touches on the infamous 99 re-occuring riff. the jiboo riff. That riff was all over the place that summer.
yeah, sorry about the rant.
Score: 1
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose Damn, I've got it. Used up my guess.
Score: 1
phootyjon Reply
phootyjon 7/31/2003 Piper
Score: 0
Fitz2001 Reply
Fitz2001 Drowned 11-2-98
Score: 0
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose First taste of having the jam and having guessed prematurely.
Stings! This one especially..
Score: 0
NoDirection Reply
NoDirection If I'm not mistaken...its already been guessed. Am I right @andrewrose?
Score: 0
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose It has not been guessed yet.
Score: 1
ucpete Reply
ucpete @andrewrose said:
First taste of having the jam and having guessed prematurely.
Stings! This one especially..
That sure makes it seem like it's a DWD from one of these shows...
Score: 0
NoDirection Reply
NoDirection 12/31/11 First Tube

Not quite right I think, but it sure sounds like a First Tube to me...
Score: 0
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose Going to keep my mouth shut now, not up to me to give any hints. Will be right in there with my second guess as soon as that hint is posted though, assuming someone doesn't get it by then..
Score: 0
FunkyCFunkyDo Reply
FunkyCFunkyDo @andrewrose said:
Well it sounded like a Down with Disease to me, so much so that I figured it was a red herring. Also sounded 2.0 so I figured P&M. Only thing is I couldn't detect it in any version that I had which is all of 2003. 4/17/04 was a blind guess.. Have never heard it but remember reading it was a scorcher. Don't hear it in any other 03 ones though. Maybe it is a Disease...
Not 4.17.04 Pebbles (but you should give it a whirl @andrewrose... heck of a first set too: Halley's -> Tweezer; Piper -> Frankenstein, Bowie are very solid renditions)

As for MJM, the blog has left me, somehow, both Stevie Wonder'd and Beethoven'd me.
Score: 0
nicu2 Reply
1.3.03 first tube?
Score: 0
nicu2 Reply
@nicu2 said:
1.3.03 first tube?
I mean 3/1/03 NOT 1/3/03...... I guess thats why they call it DOPE. :)
Score: 0
HarborSeal Reply
Rock and Roll 6/26/2010
Score: 0
PhreeDomRider Reply
PhreeDomRider 7/12/99 DWD, Figured i would guess the show in my state
Score: 0
gordansmule Reply
12.02.03 weekapaug groove
Score: 0
Thunder Reply
Thunder Seems to me like 99/00. Like @TheDeputy says, I identify that Jibboo lick mostly from that year (although I have spotted as far back as 96 and maybe earlier) and especially the summer. Maybe the Halley's from Great Woods 7.13.99?
Score: 0
tobarr4 Reply
some sort of Paug from '99....7/16/99??
Score: 0
MomaDan Reply
MomaDan Woah I actually got one. Misty Mountain Hop 7/20/99

I narrowed it down to July 99 and searched through Weakapa
Score: 3
MomaDan Reply
MomaDan oops, didn't finish. Lets just say the whammy whale call and not 2009 or 10 sound quality were the clues
Score: 0
mcgrupp81 Reply
@MomaDan said:
oops, didn't finish. Lets just say the whammy whale call and not 2009 or 10 sound quality were the clues
I threw on some Summer 99 after my son went to sleep to see if I could spot it. Good call. Confirmed at just past the 8 min mark. The New Years Eve MJM should be a fun one.
Score: 0
bl002e Phish.net Staff Reply
bl002e Well done, @MomaDan.

Technically, @andrewrose did guess first with his PM to me (figured I'd wait until someone officially won before I confirmed, even though you obviously knew it :) ). Unfortunately, there are do-overs in neither MJM nor Phish. Unless of course we're talking about a Hampton YEM.

Hope I at least brought to light a phenomenal summer '99 jam that gets lost in the glut of highlights from that tour. Here's my sales pitch to LBC when I picked this gem:

One of summer '99's most overlooked, underrated jams. Sure, it's of the type I, straight-ahead rocker variety, but they hit some of the same euphoric ground they also explored that summer in the 7/8/99 Fee, 7/10/99 CDT, 7/21/99 MLT, etc. Yet, I'm not sure even the most rabid of summer '99 fans remember much about it other than the fact that it was a great, unexpected cover choice.
Score: 1
andrewrose Reply
andrewrose @bl002e said:
Well done, @MomaDan.

Technically, @andrewrose did guess first with his PM to me (figured I'd wait until someone officially won before I confirmed, even though you obviously knew it :) ). Unfortunately, there are do-overs in neither MJM nor Phish. Unless of course we're talking about a Hampton YEM.

Hope I at least brought to light a phenomenal summer '99 jam that gets lost in the glut of highlights from that tour. Here's my sales pitch to LBC when I picked this gem:

One of summer '99's most overlooked, underrated jams. Sure, it's of the type I, straight-ahead rocker variety, but they hit some of the same euphoric ground they also explored that summer in the 7/8/99 Fee, 7/10/99 CDT, 7/21/99 MLT, etc. Yet, I'm not sure even the most rabid of summer '99 fans remember much about it other than the fact that it was a great, unexpected cover choice.
Lesson learned! That security update down-time today threw me in a panic. Glad some other underrated gems from that era (hello 12/8/99 Disease and 7/13/99 Halley's) maybe got some play as a result.
Score: 0
TheDeputy Reply
TheDeputy I didn't guess the jam, but I'm proud of my accurate analysis. I actually do know something about Phish!
Score: 0
MomaDan Reply
MomaDan I thought it was kinda funny how even though it was a rare cover the jam sounded like it could belong in any phish song.
Score: 0
unibrah Reply
Sounds exactly like a DWD jam... I would have guessed the one from DTE this past summer
Score: 0
mikh2wg Reply
mikh2wg Awww, it fell in my Summer 99 blindspot! One of the only 2 shows I didn't see that summer. Those soaring major-key themes came up again and again on that tour.
Score: 0
metawhy Reply
metawhy great pick!

very underrated show with a stout 2001 > MMHop!!
Score: 1

You must be logged in to leave a comment!

Username

Password




Register | Forgot Password

Login Register